Part One: Background Information
Number and enter
answers to ALL of the prompts in the following questions into your Research
Journal blog.
1.
What is your research topic? This should be a general area of interest at this
point. It should NOT be a research question yet.
Deep sea anglerfish
2.
Select an unfamiliar Search Engine or Metasearch Engine from the list linked in
the lesson and run a search for your topic. DO NOT use Google for this
assignment!
a. Tell me which search engine or
metasearch engine you used. Scan a few webpages from your search and answer the
following:
Newslookup.com
b. What new ideas or information
did you find about the topic?
There is a new species scientist
discovered
c. What are some subtopics you read
about in your search?
New species, oceanography, ceratoid angler
fish, evolution, and bioluminescence
d. What possible research questions
came up while you were reading?
How did a species evolve into a new
species?
What concludes it as a new species?
Have there been other new discoveries of
species with in the last 5 to 10 years?
e. List words that might be used
for future searches. Be sure to include and label at least one:
DISTINCTIVE ~ Deep
sea anglerfish; Evolution
BROAD ~ Marine
wildlife; Science
NARROW ~ Lasiognathus dinema; Evolution process of new deep sea anglerfish
RELATED ~ Bioluminescence; Natural selection
These should be
single words or short phrases indicating a single concept. For example, instead
of writing “the influence of climate change on salmon fisheries,” you would
list “climate change” “salmon” and “fisheries” as three separate search terms.
Part Two: Evaluating the Website
Whether
you are doing background research, thinking of buying a new car, looking for
health care information, or just satisfying your curiosity about any question,
you will want to ask yourself about the source of the information. This week
you will walk through the steps of evaluating one website.
Please
respond to each of the points below in your evaluation of a website of your
choice.
1. Search
the web, select one website that relates to your topic, and give me the URL.
2.
Identify the website's domain, including the suffix (for example, .org or
.net). What does that tell
you about the
website?
(.org); it is used by
a non-profit organization or advocacy groups.
3.
Authority — Scan the page for:
• Information about the sponsors
and/or authors of the page. Is there an “about us” link?
Joe Donzelli
• Are there any author names,
either individual or organizational?
Nova
Southeastern University
American
Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS)
• What are the author’s
credentials?
No
credentials were found other than being associated with Nova Southeastern
University.
4.
Currency
• Can you tell if the page has been
updated? Is there a “date last updated” or copyright date?
Copyright
date of 2016 by the American Association for the Advancement of Science is
provided. However, a public release date of August, 5 2015 is listed.
• Do you consider this page
sufficiently current for the topic you are researching?
Yes,
because the website has been recently updated and the article is a little over
a year old.
5.
Accuracy and Objectivity
• Does the page have quality
information? Are information sources documented with footnotes or links? Does
it seem as credible as information in books, journals, textbooks?
It
does appear to be accurate and objective information because the university had
conducted the discovery and research. Also, the discovering researcher, Tracey
Sutton, Ph.D., was included within the article along with other specialists in
the field. My only critique is, I wish there was more detail information on the
species. For an example, what made this a new species? What factors concluded
this?
• Why was the page put on the web?
Is the purpose to sell something or convince you of a particular point of view?
If they are making an argument, do they address conflicting opinions? What
biases can you identify?
The
webpage did not appear to push an agenda, advertise to me, or had an opinion
about the subject other than that it was a new discovery.
Part Three: Reflect
Finally, reflect on
how you will apply what you learned this week to your future research.
For future research, I will utilize
the Evaluating Internet Resources handout posted on blackboard. I found it the
most helpful part of the lesson when sifting through webpages to determine the
best source for me to use. I have been so used to using scholarly articles and databases
from WSU that when I had an assignment presented to me in my Biology course, it
required me to use an online source and I found myself confused on how to go
about this and to know for sure if the webpage I am looking at is accurate. Of course
I know a little bit of how to look for the right webpage but sometimes during
the research process, things get confusing and frustrating and the article will
be a great tool to get back on track. It is great to have a quick, step-by-step
cheat sheet to help identify whether or not a website will be a reliable and
valid source.